Department of Philosophy, Devine Word Seminary, Manila, Philippines
Review Article
Does Lewi?s Contextualism Effectively Address the Gettier Problem? A Critical Analysis of David Lewis's Epistemic Contextualism
Author(s): Khanh Trinh*
What makes knowledge possible? Can we be sure that the things we believe are true? Traditional epistemologists see
knowledge as Justified True Belief (JTB). However, this theory has a severe problem, which Edmund Gettier pointed
out and challenged in his three-page articles about the traditional analysis of knowledge in 1963. Contextualists with
regard to knowledge argue that the truth of the claim 'S knows that P' is contextually dependent is one of the
solutions that many philosophers propose to solve the problems in Gettier's cases. Among them, David Lewis, in his
paper Elusive Knowledge, proposes a solution to the Gettier problem with the rules of relevance. In this paper,
Khanh Trinh will attempt to investigate whether Lewis’s contextualism can offer a satisfactory explanation of Gettier's
scenarios. In the first part, Khanh Trinh will provide a concise.. View more»