Clinics in Mother and Child Health

Births at Home: About 411 Cases Collected in the Township of Hiheatro in the Southern Part of Togo

Baguilane Douaguibe^1*, Koffi Akpadza¹, Bingo Kignomon M’bortche¹, Tina Ayoko Ketevi¹, Francis Baramna-Bagou², Komi Migbegna², Akila Bassowa³, Dede Ajavon⁴ and Abdoul Samadou Aboubakari^{4 1}Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Sylvanus Olympio University Hospital Center, Lomé, Togo
²Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Campus University Hospital center, Lomé, Togo
³Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, University Hospital center, Kara, Togo
⁴Department of Pathology, University Teaching Hospital of Lomé, Lomé, Italy
^*Correspondence: Dr. Baguilane Douaguibe, Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Sylvanus Olympio University Hospital Center, Lomé, Togo, Email:

Received: 05-Aug-2021 Published: 26-Aug-2021, DOI: 10.35248/2090-7214.21.s8.003

Introduction

Home birth is any process of childbirth that takes place in the mother's home or any other home, whether the birth is attended by skilled or unqualified health personnel, or simply a birth which does not occur under the supervision of health personnel [1]. There are two types of out-of-hospital births: planned home births, which involve women, who choose to give birth in their homes with the help of trained health personnel, and unannounced home births or delivery on road where women enter in the active phase of labor in an unexpected way, resulting in an accidental delivery outside the hospital [2]. When home births are assisted by skilled health personnel, complications are minimized as shown in some studies [2,3].

Home births without the assistance of qualified health personnel are a source of many complications that account for maternal and / or neonatal deaths [4,5]. To improve maternal and neonatal mortality rates, childbirth should be attended by qualified health personnel, preferably in a health facility. In Togo, the maternal mortality rate is 401 deaths per 100,000 live births, the perinatal mortality rate is 27 per thousand and the birth rate assisted by skilled personnel is 59.3% [6]. These rates remain high despite the implementation of various policies to combat and reduce childbirth-related deaths. Home births do not benefit from the assistance of health personnel in Togo. What can explain that women still given birth at home despite these various health policies? This study intends to answer this question by:

• Determining the number of home births

• Describing the reasons for home births

• Describing the maternal and fetal prognosis

Methodology

The study was carried out in Hihéatro in 2019 in the southern part of Togo. Hihéatro is a township of the District of AMOU in which there are fourteen peripheral medical units, four Medico-Social centers and three Hospitals. Hihéatro is located at 26 km from Amlamé and 5 km from Atakpamé. This township has nine villages and a population of 15,748. This was a cross-sectional and a descriptive study that was conducted from January 2nd to march 30th 2019. Included in the study were women who had given birth at least once at home and who had given their consent to undergo the survey.

The study sample was randomized using a two-stage cluster survey. It is made up from the villages of the township of Hiéatro. All the villages were listed (nine villages) and each village was considered as a cluster. In each village, the concessions were drawn by lot. In drawn concessions, all women who fulfilled the inclusion criteria were interviewed.

Data was collected, using a pre-planned and pre-tested survey form, by a team of four trained interviewers under the responsibility of a supervisor. Interviews were carried out at the homes of the respondents after they have given their informed consent. The explanatory variable was the place of delivery. It was verified by the following question: who has experienced home delivery once or several times in his life? Any birth outside the approved maternity hospitals was considered as a home birth.

At the beginning of the investigation, the investigator reassured the respondents that the information they disclosed will remain anonymous and confidential. He then explained the rationale behind the study and the various data appearing on the investigation sheet. After this step, each interviewer interviewed the respondent in a location that could guarantee the confidentiality and the privacy of the interviewee. The duration of the interview with each respondent varied from 30 to 45 minutes. Data acquisition entry and tabulation operations were carried out using Epi info 6.0 software.

Variables studied were

• The frequency or number of home birth

• The Socio-demographic characteristics: age, profession, level of education; married status

• History: parity, prenatal follow-up

• Process of the home birth: reasons, staff assisting the delivery,

• Maternal-fetal prognosis

Operational Definitions

The length of “home-maternity” distance: when the distance separating the pregnant woman's home and the maternity ward is more than two kilometers. The lack of the means of transport: when the pregnant woman's family does not have the means of transport that can bring her to the maternity ward. Insufficient financial means: insufficient financial means to pay the cost of transport by car and / or to pay the costs of medical care to be provided at the hospital (the amount is less than 15,000 CFA francs) Natural obstacle: when there is an obstacle that can prevent the parturient from reaching the maternity ward: a river separating the home from the maternity ward, the rainy season, late in the night.

Results

The number of home births

A total of 411 women gave birth at home in the District under study. The average number of home births per woman is 2 with extremes of 1 and 7 births per woman. In 55.7% of cases, there were at least two home deliveries per woman (Table 1).

Table 1: Number of home births of study participants recruited from township of HIHEATRO (Togo), from January 2nd to march 30th (N=411).

The Socio-demographic characteristics

The average age of the women was 28.4 years with the extremes of 15 and 38 years. The 25-34 age groups represent 67.1% of the cases. The level of education of the women was as follows: primary education represents 39.2% and secondary education is 2.4% of cases. 58.4% of the women are illiterate. The main activity of the majority of the women was farming, representing 54.5%. Thirty-five-point three percent of these women are retails sellers. The spouses of the women interviewed were farmers and life stock breeders representing respectively 67.4% and 11.2% of cases. The majority of women are married representing 92.7% of cases. 61.6% of them were Christians. The average parity of the patients is 2. Multiparty representing 59.8% of the women.

Prenatal follow-up medical care was not carried out for women who gave birth at least three times at home in their life. They did not know whether the first two home deliveries were followed-up or not. Seventy-point six percent of those who gave birth at home for the first or second time had received at least one prenatal care. Out of these, 14.7% had undergone at least four antenatal consultations. Registered Midwives, birth attendants and permanent birth attendants were the health care personnel who provided prenatal care for these women.

Reasons for home birth

The lack of financial means was the main reason for giving birth at home. In this study, women who gave birth at home were most often assisted by their family members in 82% of cases, the traditional birth attendants in 13.6% of the cases and those who gave birth without any assistance represent 4.4% of the cases (Table 2).

Table 2: Reasons for home delivery of study participants recruited from township of HIHEATRO (Togo), January 2nd to march 30th (N=411).

Maternal and neonatal prognosis

163 women were recorded representing 39.6% of the cases who had complications and were later admitted to health facility. Maternal morbidity reached 14.1% perineum tear, 1.6% hysterectomy. Four hundred and one newborns were registered. Out of these newborns, 4.5% were stillborn and 9% of the cases did not cry at birth (Tables 3 and 4).

Table 3: Complications and morbidity during home deliveries of study participants recruited from township of HIHEATRO (Togo), from January 2nd to march 30th (N=411).

Table 4: Prognosis of the newborns of study participants recruited from township of HIHEATRO (Togo), January 2nd to march 30th (N=411).

Discussion

Number of home births and sociodemographic characteristic

The average number of home births was 1.98 or two (2) home births with extremes of 1 and 7 home births. Having a baby once at home can sometimes is explained by the surprise of the labor. Having delivered at home on numerous occasions without the assistance of trained medical personnel may be an option for these women who view pregnancy and childbirth as physiological processes and may not need medical attention or outside intervention. This option is further reinforced by the age at which these deliveries occur as registered in this study. The average age of patients was 28.4 years and the age group of 25-34 years was the most represented to the level of 67.1% of cases. A matured woman's age should be an important factor in the discernment and the responsible decision-making. But in this study this was not the case.

The majority of the patients was already adults and is supposed to make responsible decisions. This behavior can probably be explained by the fact that these women do not always have the financial autonomy and were in most of the cases dependent on their husbands. The latter, given their limited means, can choose home delivery as an option for their wives. This can be explained by the fact that, in this study the main reason that pushed women to give birth at home was insufficient financial means. Another factor that can comfort women in this choice would be their experience of motherhood, because in this study, 59.8% of the patients were multiparous. Multiparty would lead some women to run the risk of giving birth at home. Several studies state that large multiparas give birth mostly at home [7-11], since labor hours are generally noticeably in a short time in multiparas. This could be explained by the fact that these women think that having had the experience of childbirth; they can do without a skilled health provider.

This mentality in the context of this study can be in part attributable to established societal norms and the low level of education of these women because in the society under study nearly 58.4% of women were illiterate. Schooling for young girls and awareness-raising actions alone can change the situation and help reduce the rate of morbidity and mortality due to unassisted childbirth as stipulated in the previous studies [4,5]. Even if the humanization of childbirth brings women to childbirth everywhere, it is important that childbirth is attended by qualified medical personnel. Accompanied home birth would be an alternative to reduce the complications associated with unassisted home births.

Reasons for home births

The reasons that motivate women to give birth at home were insufficient financial means (36%) of the cases, lack of means of transport (28%) of the cases; the long "home-maternity" distance (24.8%) of the cases, the natural obstacle (18.5%), poor reception at the maternity wards (9.5%) of the cases. The lack of financial means is said to be related to their source of income. In this study, the main activity of the respondents was agriculture representing 54.5% of the cases. Their spouses were farmers and livestock breeders representing respectively 67.4% and 11.2% of the cases. Financial income is earned from the sale of farm products. These products are harvested by season and very often under the influence of bad weather. The good season does not always smile on everyone.

As a result, women and their families were not always ready to pay the costs of childbirth medical cares in a maternity ward. The population has always considered child delivery at a health facility as a source of huge expenses. So it is only those who have financial means that give birth at a health facility. The belief of the elderly people who feel that they have no problem with their children delivering at home. Women today must have the courage to give birth at home to avoid huge expenses for the inlaws. The availability of adequate means of transport for people was scarce in the villages. This finding is often due to the lack of the means of transport vehicles. As the villages are inaccessible to vehicles, a woman in labor should walk over a long distance before finding a transport vehicle, which turns out to be impossible overnight at times.

The most available means of transport remains the two-wheeled motorcycle or the bicycle. Transporting a pregnant woman, especially in labor, is not easy and safe on a motorcycle or on a bicycle. The availability of a motorbike at the beginning of labor is not guaranteed and the risk run by the woman and her child during the transport process makes the population opt for giving birth at home. The inaccessibility of a health center is often provoked by a natural cause such like a river or a mountain. People have to cross a river or climb a mountain before reaching a road on which they can find a means of transport. It is sometimes difficult to get around even on a motorcycle. Sometimes childbirth occurs in the process of the transport to a health center.

Maternal and neonatal prognosis

The main complications observed in this study were tears of the perineum (14.1%), placental retention (11.9%), and delivery hemorrhages (8.5%).

Maternal morbidity risk factors for placental retention and delivery hemorrhages were due to the lack of medical supervision during delivery and the lack of active management of the 3rd phase of delivery. These results can be explained by the ignorance of the rules of the obstetrical art by unqualified persons who gave birth to parturient. The tear of the perineum is related to the non-protection of the perineum and the absence of an episiotomy in its prevention. Four hundred and eleven newborns were registered. Out of these newborns, 4.4% were stillborn and 8.8% did not cry at birth.

Assisted delivery allows the skilled attendant to monitor the labor, maternal condition, and fetal condition on the one hand to make timely decisions. Home births under this context are not assisted by qualified medical personnel. This situation provokes a heavy toll on the fetus. Also, children who do not cry at birth can develop psychomotor retardation. A study on the fate of children born at home without the assistance of qualified medical personnel will make it possible to assess the real impact of these deliveries on the psychomotor development of children.

Conclusion

Home birth is a reality in Togo. The main reasons for this birthing option are based insufficient financial means, the lack of the means of transport, the long "home-maternity" distance, the natural obstacle, and the poor reception at the maternity wards where they exist. Free obstetric care and increased awareness on the importance of assisted childbirth will improve the maternal-fetal prognosis.

Declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

This study was approved by the “Comité de Bioéthique pour la Recherche en Santé (CBRS)” (Bioethics Committee for Health Research) from the Togo Ministry of Health, Ref N0: 0101/2016/MS/CAB/DGS/DPLET/CBRS).

Consent for Publication

Not applicable.

Availability of Data and Materials

Extracted data are with the authors and available for sharing on request.

Competing Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest with regard to this article.

Authors Contributions

Baguilane DOUAGUIBE was responsible for the conception of the study, participated in the study design, performed the surgery, and wrote the paper. Bingo Kignomon MBORTCHE, Tina Ayoko KETEVI, Akila BASSOWA, Dede AJAVON, Francis BAGOU-BARARMNA, Komi MIGBENYA, Abdoul Samadou ABOUBAKARI were involved in the treatment and follow up of the patient; they have reviewed the paper. They were responsible for the overall scientific management of the study and the preparation of the final paper. All the authors have read and approved the final paper to be submitted for publication.

Acknowledgements

Not applicable

REFERENCES

1. Zur M, Hadar A, Sheiner E, Mazor M. Out of hospital deliveries: Incidence, obstetrical characteristics,and perinatal outcome. Harefuah. 2003;142(1):38-41.
2. Wiegers TA, Keirse MJ, Van der Zee J, Berghs GA. Outcome of planned home and planned hospital births in low risk pregnancies: prospective study in mid-wifery practices in the Netherlands. BMJ. 1996;313(7068):1309-1313.
3. Neuhaus W, Piroth C, Kiencke P, Göhring UJ, Mallman P. A psychosocial analysis of women planning birth outside hospital. J Obstet Gynaecol. 2002;22(2):143-149.
4. Da Silva ZP, De Almeida MF, Pereira Alencar G. Accidental non-hospital birth as an indicator of risk of infant mortality. Rev Bras Saude Mater Infant. 2014;14(2):235-239.
5. Razafimanantsoa E, Robillard PY, Desveaux C, Iacobelli S, Bonsante F, et al. Unannounced births at home or "on the way" in the south of Reunion Island: 656 births in 15 years. Méd Périnat. 2017;9(1):37-46.
6. Bi Vroh JB, Tiembré I, Zengbé-Acray P, Doua JG, Dagnan S, Saracino JT. Prévalence et déterminants des accouchements à domicile dans deux quartiers précaires de la commune de Yopougon (Abidjan), Côte d’Ivoire. Dans Santé Publique. 2009; 21(5):499-506.
7. Billon M, Bagou G, Gaucher L, Duc F, Leboucher B, Riethmuller D. Accouchement inopiné extrahospitalier : prise en charge et facteur de risque. J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod. 2016; 45:285-290
8. Nguyen ML, Lefèvre P, Dreyfus M. Conséquences maternelles et néonatales des accouchements inopinés extrahospitaliers. J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod. 2015; 45(1):86-91.
9. Lukumar P, Pathmeswaran A. Factors associated with home deliveries in Thampalakamam, Trincomalee. Ceylon Med J. 2006; 51(2):59-62.
10. Ovaskainen K, Ojala R, Gissler M, Luukkaala T, Tammela O. Out-of-hospital deliveries have risen involving greater neonatal morbidity: risk factors in out-of-hospital deliveries in one university hospital region in Finland. Acta Paediatr. 2015; 104(12):1248-1252.